‘Aisha’ Review: Seeking Asylum in Ireland

1 week ago 65
  • ​​‘Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes’
  • ​​‘Bodkin’
  • ​​‘The Fall Guy’
  • ‘The Idea of You’
  • ‘Challengers’
  • ‘Unfrosted’

The “Black Panther” star Letitia Wright shows understated vulnerability in this immigrant drama by Frank Berry. Josh O’Connor (“Challengers”) also stars.

A woman in a down coat and a blue head wrap smiles at a man in a dark jacket, who is next to her, leaning on a stone wall.
Letitia Wright and Josh O’Connor in “Aisha,” a film about a young Nigerian woman petitioning for permanent residency in Ireland.Credit...Patrick Redmond/Samuel Goldwyn

May 9, 2024, 7:00 a.m. ET

AishaDirected by Frank BerryDramaNot Rated1h 34m

When an administrator says “I’m sorry” at a shelter for asylum seekers in “Aisha,” the phrase has seldom sounded so galling. An exemplar of the upending power people can wield in bureaucracies, the administrator repeatedly makes things difficult for Aisha, a young Nigerian woman petitioning for permanent residence in Ireland.

The “Black Panther” star Letitia Wright descends from the Marvel Cinematic Universe to give a quietly fierce performance as Aisha, an asylum seeker in the writer-director Frank Berry’s drama. The reasons for her request unfold during visits with her legal counsel, in video talks with her mother in Lagos and at the careful prodding of the shelter’s fledgling security guard (played with hangdog sympathy by Josh O’Connor of “Challengers”). All the while, Wright breathes deep vulnerability into Aisha’s unsurprising reticence.

At the beauty salon where she works, Aisha’s rightly cagey as she listens to her customers. But at the shelter, she turns warm, when she gives makeovers to fellow immigrants. As he did for his award-winning prison film, “Michael Inside,” Berry used nonprofessional actors with intimate experience of the system — here, Ireland’s International Protection Office, which processes asylum applications he wanted to depict. It’s a gesture that keeps the film from lapsing into melodrama.

Will Aisha convince the decision makers that she cannot safely return to Nigeria? Will Aisha and Conor’s hushed friendship bud into something more? “Aisha” resists tidy answers through the gentle force of its performances and by staying on the rebuffs and uncertainty Aisha suffers.

Aisha
Not rated. Running time: 1 hour 34 minutes. In theaters.